An Overview of Contractor Discipline in Florida

Part 2 – The Probable Cause and the Administrative Complaint

Many Florida contractors and license holders have a general understanding of the Florida
Construction Industry Licensing Board (“CILB”), but like many quasi-judicial bodies, it can
remain a mystery to those who appear in front of the CILB. Part 2 of this multipart blog post will
cover some specific information regarding the finding of probable cause and the Administrative
Complaint phases of contractor discipline in Florida.


In Florida, contractor discipline is managed by the Construction Industry Licensing
Board (CILB) under the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) pursuant
to Florida Statute Chapter 489. Think of it this way – The DBPR is the prosecutor of the offense
and the CILB is the quasi-judicial board that will act as the judge. The license holder is and
frankly should have counsel present at all CILB proceedings.


When its investigation is complete and legally sufficient, the DBPR will prepare and
submit to the probable cause panel of the appropriate regulatory board its investigative report.
The report shall contain the investigative findings and the recommendations of the DBPR
concerning the existence of probable cause. Sometimes, probable cause can be waived, can be
determined by the DBPR inhouse or will be determined by the CILB probable cause panel. The
determination as to whether probable cause exists shall be made by majority vote of a probable
cause panel of the board, or by the DBPR, as appropriate. If the probable cause panel finds that
probable cause exists, it shall direct the DBPR to file a formal administrative complaint against
the licensee.


When the DBPR has filed an Administrative Complaint against you, they will send you a
copy of a document called and Election of Rights (“EOR”). You generally have 21 days from the
date you receive the Administrative Complaint and Election of Rights form to respond. If you
fail to file your response on time, it is treated as a waiver of your right to a hearing. The board
can then enter a default final order and impose heavy fines, suspension, or license revocation.
When you fill out the DBPR EOR form, you must select only one of the following
options:


Option 1: Informal Hearing (Do not Dispute Facts). This means that you do not dispute
the material facts outlined in the Administrative Complaint, but you want to appear or submit
written/oral evidence of mitigation (reasons why the penalty should be reduced) directly to the
board before they impose fines or discipline.


Option 2: Formal Hearing (Dispute Material Facts). This means that you dispute the
factual allegations in the complaint and request a formal evidentiary hearing before an
Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) at the Division of Administrative Hearings (DOAH) in
Tallahassee. You must explicitly list which paragraphs of the complaint you are disputing.
Option 3: Waiver of Hearing Rights (Default / Settlement). This means that you waive
your right to contest the complaint or request a hearing. Instead of a strict waiver, contractors

through their attorneys often work out a settlement stipulation/consent agreement with DBPR
attorneys to negotiate reduced penalties rather than facing maximum board sanctions.
Do not check a box blindly. The choice you make permanently shapes how your license
case is handled. Because CILB violations (such as project abandonment, code violations, or
negligence under Florida Statute Chapter 489) carry severe penalties—including fines up to
$10,000 per violation, suspension, or revocation—it is strongly recommended to consult a
licensed Florida administrative law attorney who handles Chapter 120 and DBPR/CILB defense
immediately upon receipt. If you truly dispute the core facts alleged in the Administrative
Complaint, elect FORMAL HEARING. If the facts are essentially undisputed and the main issue
is the appropriate discipline, an informal hearing may be the correct posture. If unsure, err on the
side of requesting the Formal Hearing so that option is not deemed waived.
Retention of counsel familiar with construction licensing at this stage is critical and
important attention is placed on timely meeting the EOR deadline. The next segment of this blog
post will discuss what happens with the Administrative Complaint is settled or addressed at the
CILB hearing.

Free Closing Calculator
Scroll to Top
Free Closing Cost Estimate